COVID-19
AND THE HUMANITARIAN WORLD
By Shahbaz Israr Khan
Covid-19 has gripped the world
in pan-crisis with remarkable impact on
world affairs and
has/ will impact
the humanitarian interventions across the world. In this article I hereby
present humanitarian
sector dilemmas related to Covid-19 situation
which has impacted
and will further impact the humanitarian programs across the world
and need to be addressed on priority basis.
Firstly, Covid-19 impact on world's
economy has already started taking its
toll on humanitarian budget by donor countries and decrease in contributions
by individuals
leading to new perceived program priorities, for instance in Africa malaria
program and other diseases are highly impacted due budget cuts, re-routing of funds to
Covid interventions domestically and overburdened health
systems.
Covid has
to be prioritized but should not be on the expense of other diseases like
malaria, Tuberculosis and Hiv which kill hundred thousand each
year (https://www.thelancet.com/action/showPdf?pii=S2214-109X%2820%2930288-6).
In one of the recent field assessments, I met hospitals/ Integrated
health structures with complete rupture of malaria treatment and lack of
diagnostic kits in malaria season. In one of the health facilities, we found
that there were no malaria treatment/ diagnostic stocks and a two-year-old
child was only given paracetamol; as our team tested the child, he was malaria
positive, the nurse informed that he has nothing but paracetamol and no kits.
In already vulnerable population, malaria and other diseases will cause havocs.
Secondly, shrinking funds has already led to
defining new priorities and in some cases reduced activities with
some prominent international organizations closing their humanitarian programs
(https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2020/may/20/oxfam-to-close-in-18-countries-and-cut-1500-staff-amid-coronavirus-pressures).
Based on current trends it can be stipulated that the reduction of
humanitarian funds will further takes its tool across the humanitarian
organizations.
Thirdly,
the human resource mobility and duty of care is a critical issue in the current
Covid apocalypse. Already, the field activities have decreased and many field
workers are unable to arrive to the field and others are working from home,
which has impacted the effective implementation, monitoring/ evaluation of
activities. In my recent project, there were gaps in essential positions and
each one of us was doing multitasking and covering multiple positions. Such
situations can easily lead to burnouts of existing human resource in the field
due to overstretching to cover field gaps. On the flip side, we included more
our national staff in planning and organization of the activities and
realization that national staff capabilities needs to be further utilized_ a
prospect that needs to decolonize our concept of humanitarian support.
Fourthly,
psychologically humanitarians working in highly insecure contexts are already
stressed and Covid adds another complexity. I interacted several humanitarian
workers both in the field and while travelling back to home in Covid times.
There were concerns all around:
i)
What if the dear ones got ill at home, will
I be able to travel to home?
ii)
What will happen if I got infected with
COVID and unable to arrive home? Most organizations have medical evacuation
policies but are highly complicated during the Covid times;
iii)
What will happen if I will get stuck on my
transit due to cancellation of flights to my home country? One of our
colleagues actually got stuck in Addis for 10 days at airport due to
cancellation of onward-flights. It was psychologically very challenging to be
stuck inside the airport for such a long time.
There
is no magic bullet to above mentioned issues as all of us are new to such a
different world. Some recommendations to deal the above-mentioned problems are:
-
Programing in the new financial and
epidemiological context has to be done in a holistic manner; instead of cuts
on/ reduction of ongoing programs, organizations should review internal
financial inefficiencies and high bureaucratic expenses. Funds must reach to
the beneficiaries rather spending on HQ expenses, lucrative salaries, luxurious
buildings and high paid consultants as is the norm of many international
organizations.
-
More national/ local funding possibilities
to be explored.
-
In current situation, the humanitarian
sector has to strategize effective implementation of programs according to
humanitarian priorities without deprioritizing ongoing interventions to
neutralize the Covid drainage impact on killer diseases.
-
Psycho-social support to existing field
workers should be consolidated.
-
International organizations should readopt
the monitoring systems (inclusion of strong community-based models) and mobile
feedbacks.
-
In light of new field reality and organize
advocacy with governments on access of humanitarian workers in the field (UN
under banner of WFP has already started flights but cannot match the overall
demand in the field in addition to layers of transit complexities and daily
changing immigration rules of different countries).
- I have always been advocating the empowerment of national staff and involvement in decision making processes to avoid colonial approaches, such a situation as Covid further consolidates the argument that nationalization of key positions and involving national staff in key decision-making process is important for the continuity of operations and avoid above mentioned issues.
--------------------------
You can send your comments or feedback to shahbazasrar@yahoo.com
Dear Shahbaz, I admire ur efforts in highlighting the core issues that humanitarians and the vulnerable population face in this difficult time. Unfortunately, Covid 19 has overshadowed the other important programs as u mentioned; in fact,these programs hv been deliberately abandoned due to political & financial reasons. These is no comprehensive approach to this issue. Govt is compromising on my things during this pandemic. Instead of conselling pple, govts hv scared their pple.
ReplyDeleteAs for empowering the national staff is concerned, every org must empower the national staff and enhance thier capability. To make a program sustainable, orgs hv to include national staff in devision making process. In fact, national staff should be in the process of designing the program.
Thanks for writing ur experience
Regards,
Thank you Saeed.
DeleteIncisive piece. Thanks for penning this, Dr Shahbaz
ReplyDeleteThank you Ahsan
DeleteInspiring!
ReplyDeleteThanks dear!
DeleteInspiring article with excellent demonstration
ReplyDeleteThank you!
DeleteInspiring article with excellent demonstration
ReplyDeleteInspiring article with excellent demonstration
ReplyDeleteVery rich insight shared by Dr Shahbaz. One thing notable in the current context for humanitarian organization is to develop integrated efforts with cooperation of every single country. This will assist the pragmatic use of resources which will not impact other interventions. The present system collapsed because of the voice to keep social distance from beginning. Rather the prevention could have been possible via using preventive measures like its observed finally. Anyhow, monopolistic approach of one organization - need to be addressed - "decolonized" to counter such disasters by preventing chaotic situation.
ReplyDeleteGood luck brother.
The suggestion of reducing HQs costs instead of cutting field position makes sense for ensuring continuity of basic service. Some organisations have already started cutting field position rather than cutting their expenses at HQ level. The telecommuting mode is also not a viable option in the humanitarian sector though it may work in corporate sector. Anyway very kudos Mr. Shabaz for sharing this informative article.
ReplyDeleteThe suggestion of reducing HQs costs instead of cutting field position makes sense for ensuring continuity of basic service. Some organisations have already started cutting field position rather than cutting their expenses at HQ level. The telecommuting mode is also not a viable option in the humanitarian sector though it may work in corporate sector. Anyway very kudos Mr. Shabaz for sharing this informative article.
DeleteThank you Basheer SB.
DeleteBashir ahmad!
ReplyDeleteHey Shahbaz, I find this article very interesting and the propositions are just the most appropriate. It will help to reduce the impact of the Global crisis
ReplyDeleteThank you
DeleteCongratulation..
ReplyDeleteThank you dear
Delete